Magento Upgrade Audit Checklist: What to Review Before Any Upgrade

Magento upgrades are often delayed because store owners fear one thing:

“What if something breaks?”

That fear is valid — most failed Magento upgrades don’t fail because of the upgrade itself, but because hidden risks were never reviewed beforehand.

This checklist explains what should be reviewed before any Magento upgrade, why it matters, and how store owners can avoid costly surprises.

No technical jargon. Just clarity.

Why a Magento Upgrade Audit Matters

Magento upgrades introduce:

  • Code changes
  • Dependency updates
  • Security fixes
  • Platform behavior changes

If your store already has:

  • Custom code
  • Third-party extensions
  • Performance bottlenecks
  • Outdated patches

An upgrade can expose problems instantly.

An upgrade audit helps identify:

  • What’s safe to upgrade
  • What needs fixing first
  • What can wait
  • What may break during upgrade

An audit also helps align expectations with a realistic Magento upgrade timeline, so store owners understand what should be done before, during, and after the upgrade.

At this stage, many store owners also want to understand whether a free vs paid Magento audit makes sense for their store size, customizations, and upgrade complexity.

Magento Upgrade Audit Checklist (Store-Owner Friendly)

1️⃣ Magento Version & Patch Level

Before upgrading, confirm:

  • Current Magento version
  • Applied security patches
  • End-of-support timelines

Outdated versions increase:

  • Security exposure
  • Upgrade complexity
  • Compatibility issues

2️⃣ Extension Compatibility Review

Every extension should be checked for:

  • Compatibility with target Magento version
  • Active maintenance by the vendor
  • Known conflicts

Many upgrade failures happen because:

“One small extension broke the checkout.”

3️⃣ Custom Code & Overrides Audit

Review:

  • Core overrides
  • Custom modules
  • Theme customizations
  • Checkout modifications

Questions to answer:

  • Is the code upgrade-safe?
  • Is it documented?
  • Can it be refactored?

4️⃣ Database & Indexing Health

Check for:

  • Long-running queries
  • Broken indexers
  • Cron failures
  • Data inconsistencies

Database issues often surface after upgrades — not immediately.

5️⃣ Performance & Core Web Vitals Snapshot

Before upgrading, establish:

  • Baseline performance
  • Checkout speed
  • Mobile experience
  • Page load bottlenecks

Upgrades can change performance behavior — knowing the baseline prevents confusion later.

6️⃣ Security Risk Exposure

Review:

  • Known vulnerabilities
  • Admin exposure
  • Checkout security risks
  • API access points

Upgrading without addressing security gaps can leave the store exposed even after upgrade.

This is why understanding Magento security patches is critical before upgrading, not after issues surface.

7️⃣ Third-Party Integrations

Audit integrations like:

  • Payment gateways
  • Shipping services
  • ERP / CRM
  • Marketing tools

Integrations often fail silently after upgrades.

8️⃣ Environment Readiness

Ensure:

  • Proper staging environment
  • Backup and rollback plan
  • Version control in place

Upgrading directly on production is one of the costliest mistakes.

Common Mistakes Store Owners Make Before Upgrades

  • Skipping audits to save time
  • Assuming extensions will “just work”
  • Ignoring performance warnings
  • Relying only on version compatibility lists
  • Treating upgrades as a one-click task

Ironically, these shortcuts increase risk and cost.

Free vs Paid Magento Upgrade Audit (Quick Context)

A free audit typically highlights:

  • High-risk areas
  • Upgrade blockers
  • Immediate concerns

A paid deep audit may be needed for:

  • Large catalogs
  • Heavy customizations
  • Complex integrations

Starting small gives clarity without commitment.

Final Thought

Magento upgrades don’t fail randomly.

They fail because:

  • Risks were hidden
  • Assumptions were made
  • Preparation was skipped

A simple upgrade audit checklist prevents:

  • Emergency rollbacks
  • Checkout failures
  • Lost revenue
  • Upgrade regret

Clarity before action always costs less than fixing surprises later.

👉 Planning a Magento Upgrade?

Before upgrading, many store owners start with a free Magento upgrade audit to identify risks, understand readiness, and plan next steps — without pressure or obligation.